Education

Justice Department Sues Penn State Over In-State Tuition for Undocumented Students

admin · · 7 min read

Students walking across the Penn State University Park campus in front of a red-brick academic hall with white columns.

The U.S. Department of Justice has sued Pennsylvania State University over a policy that lets some undocumented students pay in-state tuition, escalating a nationwide legal campaign that has now moved from state laws to individual universities.

The 14-page complaint, filed November 5 in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania, asks a federal judge to declare Penn State’s policy unconstitutional and to permanently block the university from enforcing it — or from adopting any similar policy in the future. It is the Justice Department’s 27th lawsuit challenging in-state tuition for undocumented students.

What the lawsuit says

At the center of the case is Penn State’s undocumented-student policy, which allows students without lawful immigration status to qualify for Pennsylvania resident tuition if they attended an accredited Pennsylvania high school for four years and graduated, or earned a Pennsylvania GED. The policy carries no lawful-presence requirement.

The Justice Department argues the policy violates a 1996 federal law, 8 U.S.C. Section 1623, which bars a person who is not lawfully present in the United States from receiving a postsecondary education benefit based on residence in a state unless U.S. citizens are eligible for the same benefit regardless of where they live. A second count relies on 8 U.S.C. Section 1621(d), which permits states to extend public benefits to people without lawful status only through a state law enacted after August 22, 1996, that affirmatively provides for that eligibility.

“The Department of Justice today continues its efforts to ensure that no state law or university policy gives preferential treatment to illegal aliens over our Nation’s own citizens,” Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward Jr. said in a statement announcing the lawsuit. “Congress long ago made clear that states, through their public universities, cannot give reduced tuition to illegal aliens not available to all Americans.”

Penn State is named alongside its Board of Trustees as a defendant. A university spokesperson told Inside Higher Ed that Penn State was aware of the complaint and was looking into it, and declined to comment further.

The policy and the price gap

The financial stakes for students are large. For the 2026-27 academic year, first- and second-year students at Penn State’s University Park campus pay $21,198 in tuition and fees as Pennsylvania residents, compared with $44,894 as nonresidents — a difference of $23,696 per year.

Pennsylvania has no state law on in-state tuition for undocumented students, which is what makes this case different from most of the Justice Department’s earlier filings. The complaint targets a university policy rather than a statute, and the department does not say how many students currently pay in-state rates under the policy.

More than 500,000 undocumented students are enrolled in higher education across the country, according to data from the Higher Ed Immigration Portal. Roughly 13,000 of them attend college in Pennsylvania.

A campaign now aimed at universities

The Penn State filing marks a new phase in the administration’s campaign. Over the span of less than 18 months, the Justice Department sued all 24 states and Washington, D.C., that had policies making undocumented students eligible for in-state tuition. After finishing that sweep, it turned to individual institutions, first suing the University of Delaware in October for a similar policy. Penn State is the second university sued directly.

The legal outcomes so far have been mixed. Last month, a federal judge allowed Virginia’s policy to stand, reasoning that it lets students qualify for in-state tuition in several different ways, including by attending high school in the state, and that certain U.S. citizens from other states — such as the children of active-duty service members who filed taxes in Virginia — can also qualify. The Justice Department, meanwhile, points to favorable orders in Texas, Kentucky, Oklahoma, Nebraska, Illinois and Kansas.

Advocates for undocumented students say the lawsuits misread the 1996 law. Thomas A. Saenz, president and general counsel of the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund, has previously told Inside Higher Ed that the bipartisan policies enacted in 24 states and Washington, D.C., since 2001 were based on the interpretation that they are constitutional as long as at least one U.S. citizen from another state could qualify. Saenz noted the policies had never been challenged before, including during the first Trump administration. Advocates have called the lawsuits a coordinated attack on undocumented students’ rights, arguing that many of the students were brought to the United States as small children and that paying in-state tuition gives them a pathway to work authorization, good jobs and a way to give back to the communities they grew up in.

Why this matters

The Penn State case tests whether the Justice Department’s legal theory can reach beyond state legislatures to the policies of public universities themselves. If the department prevails, other universities with similar residency rules could face the same challenge — and students who qualified for in-state rates could see their tuition bills more than double.

The case also lands amid a broader squeeze on college access. Florida delayed a vote on letting some undocumented students attend public universities, and international students at U.S. colleges fell to 1.1 million as new arrivals dropped 18%, according to the Open Doors 2026 report. At the same time, colleges are warning that a proposed $70,000 fee on Optional Practical Training could cost them tens of millions of dollars. For families already weighing the cost of a degree, the outcome in Pennsylvania will be closely watched.

What happens next

Nothing changes for enrolled students yet. The Justice Department’s filing seeks a permanent injunction but includes no emergency motion, so any change to tuition billing would follow a court ruling. Penn State has not yet filed its answer, and no hearing date has been set. The case will be decided by a federal judge in the Middle District of Pennsylvania — not by a press release — and the university will have the opportunity to defend its policy in court.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is the Justice Department suing Penn State?

The department says Penn State’s policy violates federal law by giving in-state tuition to undocumented students while denying the same reduced rate to U.S. citizens who live outside Pennsylvania. It is the department’s 27th lawsuit challenging in-state tuition for undocumented students, and the second aimed directly at a university.

What is Penn State’s in-state tuition policy for undocumented students?

Under the policy, students without lawful immigration status can qualify for Pennsylvania resident tuition if they attended an accredited Pennsylvania high school for four years and graduated, or earned a Pennsylvania GED. The policy has no lawful-presence requirement.

How much is the tuition difference?

For 2026-27, first- and second-year students at University Park pay $21,198 per year as Pennsylvania residents, compared with $44,894 as nonresidents — a gap of $23,696 per year.

Does the lawsuit change tuition for current students?

No. The lawsuit asks a court to block the policy, but no judge has ruled and no emergency order has been sought. Students’ tuition rates will not change unless and until a court decides the case.

The Penn State lawsuit is the clearest sign yet that the Justice Department’s tuition campaign is expanding from state capitols to campus administrations. With the case now before a federal judge, the fight over who qualifies for a public university’s lowest tuition rate — and what federal law actually requires — is moving into its next phase.

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *