Money Is the Biggest Barrier to College Success, 72% of Campus Leaders Say

Money — not motivation — is the biggest obstacle standing between American college students and a degree. That is the central finding of Inside Higher Ed’s third annual Survey of College and University Student Success Administrators, conducted with Hanover Research and published November 12. Seventy-two percent of the 271 student success leaders surveyed named insufficient financial aid, or the need to work long hours to cover living costs, as the leading challenge to students’ academic success and persistence.
The survey, conducted August 22 through October 5, drew mostly on student-affairs executives at public and private nonprofit colleges and universities. Its margin of error is plus or minus six percentage points. The picture it paints is consistent: campus leaders are confident in the education their institutions deliver, but far less confident in their ability to clear the financial and personal barriers that keep students from finishing.
What is holding students back
When administrators were asked to pick the biggest barriers to student success, money led by a wide margin. Mental and behavioral health challenges ranked second, cited by 55 percent, followed by gaps in academic preparation at 47 percent and basic needs insecurity — chronic housing instability, food insecurity, or unreliable transportation — at 33 percent. Far fewer named coursework relevance (22 percent), disengagement (20 percent), confusing aid processes (19 percent), or disengaging teaching (12 percent).
The pressure is sharpest at community colleges, where basic needs insecurity (65 percent) is nearly as prominent as financial constraints (67 percent).
Students themselves tell a similar story. Preliminary data from the 2026-27 Student Voice survey by Inside Higher Ed and Generation Lab shows undergraduates rank mental health challenges first and financial pressure second among barriers to their own success. Six in 10 said they had gone without food, medical care, mental health care, transportation, or sleep in the past year because they could not afford it.
Colleges believe in their teaching — but not their capacity
The survey’s most striking tension is between confidence and capacity. Nearly all administrators — 94 percent — rated the quality of undergraduate education at their institution as good (48 percent) or excellent (46 percent). Most agreed students trust their institution (92 percent) and employers trust graduates’ skills (89 percent).
But when leaders were asked what limits their own teams, the answers came back to resources. Among the 233 administrators who wrote in about the biggest internal barriers to innovating around student success, funding appeared in about half of the responses and staffing or personnel constraints in roughly a third. Organizational barriers — leadership structures, competing priorities, silos between departments — were another recurring theme.
Data is a particular weak spot. Fewer than half of respondents (48 percent) said their institution is very or extremely effective at collecting student success data, and just 39 percent said the same about using it to inform decisions. Only 35 percent rated their institution highly on building a data culture — most of these numbers virtually unchanged from 2024 and 2025.
“Technology is getting better and better at sharing data, but people are not,” said Elliot Felix, a student success consultant and author of “The Connected College.” He argued that institutions should stop trying to do more with less and instead focus: “The goal shouldn’t be do more with less, it should be to focus so you can do less with more.”
An independent survey points the same way: a June survey of 459 student success leaders by the consulting firm EAB found 71 percent saying students’ financial challenges hurt retention, with budget constraints (60 percent) and staffing shortages (55 percent) the top barriers to meeting student success goals.
The emergency aid students never find
One of the survey’s clearest gaps is not a lack of help, but a lack of connection to it. Although 75 percent of leaders said their institution offers emergency financial aid, just 35 percent said students are aware of it and regularly use it. And only 16 percent said students understand the total cost of attendance — tuition, fees, and living expenses — very or extremely clearly, virtually unchanged from last year despite growing national attention to cost transparency.
That disconnect matters because the cost problem is getting worse, not better. The Pell Grant program faces a $17 billion shortfall this year, and the maximum Pell award still covers less than a third of the cost of a public four-year college, down from more than three-quarters when the program began. For students working long hours to cover rent and food, an emergency grant they never hear about is no help at all.
Asked in write-ins for the single most effective change their institution could make, administrators most frequently called for more need-based financial aid and more staff — and for connecting students with help before difficulties, not after.
Mental health and federal policy weigh on students
Mental health is the second-biggest barrier in the survey, and leaders say it is not easing. While 81 percent rated their institution’s efforts to promote general undergraduate well-being as good or excellent, 77 percent agreed that mental health challenges continue to be a primary driver of academic difficulties and students stopping out. There are some encouraging signs: more than three-fourths (78 percent) said students are seeking mental health resources earlier, before reaching a crisis. But just 9 percent agreed that the severity of students’ struggles has decreased over the past year.
Campus climate is improving: 30 percent said their institution does an excellent job promoting a positive atmosphere, up from 19 percent in 2024.
The survey also captures how Washington is reaching into campus life. Forty-six percent of leaders said recent regulatory or legislative changes have negatively affected undergraduate students’ sense of belonging at their institution, and similar shares reported negative effects on staff workload (46 percent) and staff budgets (43 percent). Nearly half (45 percent) reported significant federal policy-related declines in international applications or enrollment, up from 29 percent in 2025. Most also said the One Big Beautiful Bill Act is limiting undergraduate access, 21 percent significantly. The Senate passed the RISE Act to ease college disability accommodations this month — it would let students use high school documentation instead of paying for new testing — but the House must act by year’s end or the effort starts over in 2027.
AI draws optimism — with clear limits
Leaders are notably bullish on artificial intelligence, even though most have not yet seen it help students directly. Nearly three-quarters (74 percent) said their institution is at least somewhat effective at helping students understand how, when, and whether to use generative AI in academic settings, up from 57 percent in 2025. And 86 percent said AI has increased efficiency for faculty and staff in drafting communications and summarizing information.
But nearly a third (32 percent) said they have not yet detected measurable improvements from AI in the student experience, and 27 percent were not sure. The clearest reported student gains were in retention and early intervention and in career services, cited by 21 percent each. Looking ahead three years, 69 percent see significant or transformative potential for AI to improve students’ interactions with general administrative and campus services.
Students, for their part, have clear priorities for responsible AI use, according to the Student Voice survey: helping students learn rather than simply doing work for them (65 percent), being transparent about when and how AI is being used (60 percent), and protecting students’ privacy and personal information (54 percent). “AI is a tool and not a crutch,” one administrator wrote in the survey.
Why this matters
The survey lands during American Education Week (November 16-20), and its message is uncomfortable for a sector that prides itself on access. Colleges are broadly confident in what they teach. What they doubt is whether students can afford to stay long enough to learn it, and whether campuses have the people and systems to catch them when money runs short.
The stakes are concrete: students who stop out over a missed rent payment rarely come back on schedule, if they come back at all. The tools that could help — emergency aid, proactive advising, clearer cost information — already exist on most campuses; the missing piece is the capacity to connect students with support before a crisis, not after.
Career preparation shows the same split. Some 83 percent of administrators agreed that students at their institution earn the degrees and certificates needed to enter their chosen fields, but fewer expressed confidence in students’ access to experiential learning (69 percent) or their ability to articulate specific skills to employers (61 percent). For all the talk that three-year degrees are booming as a cheaper, faster route through college, the survey is a reminder that speed is not the same as support: a shorter degree still leaves a student working nights to pay for it.
Mark Milliron, president of National University, which serves many nontraditional students balancing college with employment, caregiving, and military service, said the findings point to a deeper redesign. “Without the right systems, we cannot produce the data and insights that guide decision-making, reduce friction in operations and inform personalized student support,” he said. “It needs to be reflected in how the university designs learning, builds relationships and organizes support from the beginning.”
Frequently asked questions
What is the Inside Higher Ed student success survey?
Inside Higher Ed’s third annual Survey of College and University Student Success Administrators, conducted with Hanover Research, surveyed 271 student success leaders — mostly student-affairs executives at public and private nonprofit institutions — between August 22 and October 5, 2026. The margin of error is plus or minus six percentage points. Inside Higher Ed will discuss the results in a free webcast on Wednesday, December 9, at 2 p.m. Eastern.
Why don’t students use the emergency aid their colleges offer?
It points to an awareness gap: 75 percent of institutions offer emergency financial aid, yet only 35 percent of leaders say students know about it and use it regularly, and only 16 percent say students understand the total cost of attendance very or extremely clearly. Leaders say the fix is earlier, proactive outreach.
What do students want from AI on campus?
According to the Student Voice survey, students most want AI to help them learn rather than simply do their work (65 percent), along with transparency about when AI is being used (60 percent) and protection of their privacy (54 percent).
The survey’s bottom line: student success is the priority, and capacity is the challenge. Until campuses fund the staff, aid, and systems to match, the biggest barrier to a degree will remain the one students carry in their wallets.
Sources
- Inside Higher Ed, “The Priority? Student Success. The Challenge? Capacity.” (Nov 12, 2026)
- Inside Higher Ed, 2026 Survey of College and University Student Success Administrators (report)
- Inside Higher Ed, “Survey: Student Success Leaders Weigh In Ahead of 2027” (Nov 12, 2026)
- Inside Higher Ed, “Student Support Needs Outpace College Capacity” (EAB survey, Sept 3, 2026)


