Education

New Bipartisan Report Tells Colleges How to Survive the “Back to the States” Era

admin · · 8 min read

University campus with students walking past academic buildings under an American flag, illustrating the back to the states era in higher education.

A bipartisan group of more than 100 college leaders, policymakers, business executives and students has a blunt message for American higher education: Washington is stepping back, enrollment is shrinking, and colleges that try to be everything to everyone will not survive the squeeze. The prescription, laid out in a report released last week by Johns Hopkins University and the American Enterprise Institute, is to pick a clear mission, shrink with purpose where necessary, and prove to students, families and taxpayers that a degree is worth the price.

The report, “Leading Colleges and Universities in a ‘Back to the States’ Era: Recommendations from a Bipartisan Summit of Leaders and Students,” draws on a working summit held July 29, 2026. Its authors are Gerard Robinson of the American Enterprise Institute, Joshua Travis Brown of the Johns Hopkins University School of Education, and Stephanie Buckenmeyer, a Johns Hopkins research and teaching assistant. Drawing on more than 200 pages of transcripts, notes and survey responses, it identifies five areas where colleges must act: competing identities, changing demand, organizational sustainability, perceived value and transformational experience.

A summit built around students, not just leaders

What sets the report apart from other recent diagnoses of higher education is who was in the room. Students sat at every table, in 14 work groups alongside university presidents, board members and participants from government, industry and philanthropy. Students from Johns Hopkins, the University of Virginia, Barnard College and McNeese State University challenged leaders’ ideas on the spot, and their objections shaped the recommendations. “When decisions about students are on the table, students belong at it,” the report concludes.

Why Washington is stepping back

The report’s starting point is that three supports American higher education has long relied on are weakening at the same time: a ready supply of students, public confidence and federal funding. The number of American high school graduates was expected to peak in 2025 and is projected to decline for more than a decade. Confidence in higher education has fallen sharply over the past decade, and families increasingly question whether a degree is worth its price.

At the same moment, Washington is shifting more of the burden of funding and overseeing higher education onto states and institutions. The Trump administration has cut the Department of Education’s workforce roughly in half and begun transferring its programs to the Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services, the Interior and State. It has frozen or terminated thousands of federal research grants and sought to cap the indirect-cost payments that sustain university research infrastructure. The 2025 reconciliation law ended Grad PLUS loans and capped federal borrowing for graduate and professional students, and an executive order on accreditation invited new accrediting bodies to compete with established ones.

One state higher education leader at the summit put the stakes plainly: the state is projected to lose a third of its incoming freshmen by 2036, the system will contract by one-third, and four to five private institutions will close.

The five areas where colleges must act

First, competing identities. Many colleges function as several organizations under one name, juggling research prestige, athletic expansion and workforce training — each claiming attention and money. “An institution torn between research prestige, athletic expansion, and workforce training risks serving none well,” one participant said. The report urges boards and presidents to answer a simple question — “Why do we exist?” — and align programs with the answer, even if that means becoming narrower and exceptionally good at fewer things.

Second, changing demand. The enrollment decline is uneven. It has hit hardest at institutions with the worst outcomes — lower graduation rates, lower graduate earnings and more student loan defaults — while schools with the best outcomes have actually seen enrollments increase over the past 15 years. Students are still choosing college, the report argues; they are just choosing more carefully. Colleges must clear bureaucratic hurdles, including accreditation rules that discourage change, and test flexible models on a small scale before adopting them widely.

Third, organizational sustainability. Colleges are built to add, not subtract. “Higher education is really good at adding things but does a really bad job at getting rid of things,” one participant said. Programs and administrative layers accumulate faster than they are reviewed, and costs rise with them. The report urges leaders to contract intentionally rather than by default, and suggests states fund strategic downsizing — helping institutions become smaller while remaining financially sustainable — instead of rewarding only new programs and enrollment growth. Research should likewise follow mission and regional needs.

Fourth, perceived value. The public feels shut out of the academy, participants said, and the gap shows up in choices families can see, such as who teaches introductory courses. One participant criticized a system that charges an 18-year-old $70,000 a year to be taught introductory economics by someone who does not see teaching as the job. The report calls for transparent pricing — financial aid letters whose “strategic ambiguity supports the institution, not the student” — and for measuring value in terms broader than earnings, since society needs social workers, teachers, ministers and artists whose first-year salaries will never look impressive on a spreadsheet.

Fifth, transformational experience. Students follow different paths, but college systems are still highly standardized and difficult to navigate. Students drop out for reasons that have nothing to do with ability: a class scheduled when they have no car, no child care and bills to pay. The report urges flexible, competency-based models built around students’ lives, with support for transportation, child care and advising. It also calls for data systems that communicate across platforms so institutions can intervene before a student fails, and for comprehensive AI strategies: 99 percent of employers in one survey said they expect all employees to be proficient in AI within five years, yet 95 percent of faculty said they themselves are not proficient. “AI should be viewed as a tool that enhances learning rather than replac[ing] it,” one work group wrote.

Why this matters

The report lands at a moment when the pressures it describes are already visible on campuses. The Pell Grant program faces a $17 billion shortfall. New data show international students at U.S. colleges fell to 1.1 million, with first-time arrivals down 18 percent. And colleges also warn that a proposed $70,000 fee on Optional Practical Training could cost them tens of millions and end the program. The report’s argument is that none of these problems has a single monetary fix or a one-party solution — and that the leaders who must now answer for them are governors, governing boards and university presidents, not Washington.

Latest developments

In a column published Monday, Brown, one of the report’s authors, welcomed the report and argued that prescriptions for higher education’s future align more than the polarized debate suggests. Whether governing boards and state legislatures adopt the action items — or whether the report joins the shelf of diagnoses — is the question to watch now.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the “back to the states” era?

It is the report’s name for a shift in which the federal government is returning responsibility for funding and overseeing higher education to states and institutions — leaving governors, boards and presidents to carry more of the burden with fewer students and less public trust.

Who wrote the report?

Gerard Robinson of the American Enterprise Institute, Joshua Travis Brown of the Johns Hopkins University School of Education, and Stephanie Buckenmeyer of Johns Hopkins. It draws on a bipartisan policy summit held July 29, 2026, with more than 100 participants from the academy, government, industry and philanthropy, including current college students.

What are the five focal areas in the report?

Competing identities, changing demand, organizational sustainability, perceived value and transformational experience. Each section states two assertions drawn from the summit and closes with action items for governing boards, university presidents and legislators.

What does the report say colleges should do about AI?

It says institutions need a comprehensive data and AI strategy, not a defensive posture. Students argued that treating AI mainly as a cheating threat leaves graduates unprepared for employers who expect AI skills, so colleges should teach students and faculty to use AI effectively and ethically.

The report’s final message is deliberately modest: none of this requires a large new federal program. The harder part is implementation — and, the authors argue, that work starts with listening to the students the decisions affect. As one undergraduate at the summit said, “Reform should keep the useful parts of college while making education more affordable, flexible, and connected to real student needs.”

Sources: American Enterprise Institute, Inside Higher Ed, Johns Hopkins University School of Education

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *